How do we become a sitter’s favorite family?

Published:

Updated:

boy with crown on head

Do you want to make SURE your sitter loves working in your home? Or, are you wondering why you don’t seem to get any sitters back more than once?

Sitters can accept or decline any placement request, and their answer doesn’t always have to do with the kids.

Through mannnnyyy years of sitter feedback, we have discovered that some families don’t offer as much incentive to return as others. Some are small things, some are outright disrespectful, but overall, we’re happy to share a few ways to help you become a Favorite Super Family.

  • Offering to cover a car/ride home
    This is by FAR the most mentioned. For sitters who don’t drive, this can be a huge deciding factor in whether to accept a placement. We know that this isn’t in everyone’s budget, but if you can swing it, your sitter will definitely notice.  If your sitter drove? Walk them to their car. Again, always mentioned.
  • Don’t make the money awkward
    Everyone knows the rate before the placement starts and knows that payment happens at the end of the night. Please show respect and pay right at the end of the placement, not the next morning or a few days after. 

    ALSO, TIPPING?
    This is not expected (like you might in a restaurant) and you certainly don’t need to be just throwing handfuls of money at them to get them to return, but rounding up to the next 30mins, paying for the time you booked even though you came home early, or ordering a rideshare as mentioned above — all are considered tips and go a long way in the side-hustle, hustle.
  • Give them the info they need
    We have created a form that you can download, fill out, and leave for each sitter you book. It includes lots of basic info, plus things that might get forgotten in a quick handoff. Keep this form to use again and again!
  • Be clear about the food
    This is a big one. Guiding rule: if a sitter is serving a kid meal or is at your house during a general mealtime, the sitter will probably need to eat too. If you are open to the sitter eating food in your house, great. If not, that’s okay too – just make sure they know to bring their own. Even just a “feel free to help yourself to whatever” is nice – they aren’t going to (or shouldn’t) just dive into your fridge without permission.
  • Let the kids know who is in charge
    Having the kids hear you lay out the rules of the night (bedtime, screen time rules, etc.) to your sitter ensures that everyone hears the same thing. It sounds small, but it goes a long way.

Some that feel obvious (but apparently aren’t):

  • Show them around your house: This one often gets overlooked. Sitters will be in your home with your kid(s) — make sure they know where they are going and where to find things (kid bathroom vs. guest bathroom, etc.), diaper pail, etc.
  • Welcome this sitter into your home: Seems simple enough, but answering the door like you want your sitter to be there is major. They are not expecting a perfect home or perfect children — chaos and kid-life is definitely part of the job. Just let them know you are happy they are there. Extra points if you ask them about their life outside of sitting and show an interest in who they are as a person.
  • Explain your TV remote: Some of you have crazy remotes and entertainment systems. If you have something that warrants instructions, please share them.
  • Be respectful of your sitter’s time: If you are running late, even if just by a few minutes, let them know. If you want to stay out later than originally booked, ask your sitter with enough time to get back by the original end time, if they say no. It’s rarely a problem for them to stay, but don’t assume anything. Also, if they DO stay, make sure they know how much you appreciate it.
  • Share some chit-chat at the end of the placement: This does not mean you need to hang out with your sitter and solve the world’s problems at midnight — just a quick conversation about how things went, how the kids did, and if there was anything to report. This is another small way to show them you appreciate the time they spent with your kids.

The Takeaway: Treating your sitter like a human being, appreciating their time, and prioritizing setting them up for success goes a long way toward getting a sitter to return again and again. Yes, this is a job, but it’s also with your kids, in your home, and by nature, it’s a very personal relationship that needs respect.

Tori Ulrich Avatar

Related Posts

  • How do I INTERVIEW a nanny or babysitter?

    How do I INTERVIEW a nanny or babysitter?

    Learn how to interview a nanny or babysitter with practical questions, red flags to watch for, and tips to help you hire the right caregiver for your family.

  • How do I FIND a nanny or babysitter?

    How do I FIND a nanny or babysitter?

    Learn how to find the right nanny or babysitter by defining your family’s needs, wants, household expectations, and ideal candidate qualities before you search.

  • Why work with Super Sitters for event childcare?

    Why work with Super Sitters for event childcare?

    Discover professional event childcare with Super Sitters, including dedicated managers, screened caregivers, curated activities, and day-of support.

Explore Our Services

Chicago’s trusted childcare for home, hotels, events, and weddings